Indiana School Vouchers 2025: Your Family's Complete Guide to New Benefits
Indiana plans to make school vouchers accessible to every family in the state. This bold move marks a fundamental change in educational funding policy. Starting June 2026, all Indiana families can qualify for vouchers whatever their income level. The state expects to spend around $93 million on this expansion. The voucher program has reached an all-time high and now serves more than 70,000 students.
School vouchers let parents direct state education funds toward private school tuition. This gives families more choices about their children's education. Indiana joins other states that have embraced universal voucher programs. The state dedicates nearly 47% of its $46 billion biennial budget to K-12 education. These changes show the state's commitment to educational freedom. This piece will help you understand the expanded benefits that await your family.
Indiana's School Voucher Expansion: What Families Need to Know
Indiana's voucher program has grown from a small initiative into a broad educational choice that helps tens of thousands of Hoosier families. The Indiana Choice Scholarship Program now serves in the 2023-24 school year—a record 31% jump from last year 70,095 students [1].
Overview of the 2025 changes
The biggest change for Indiana families removes all income limits for voucher eligibility starting June 2026 [2]. Right now, families can qualify if they earn up to 400% of the federal free and reduced lunch program. This means a family of four that makes up to $230,880 each year can get vouchers [1]. These changes show how the program has expanded over the last several years.
Families can apply during two periods in the 2025-2026 school year:
• First application period: March 1 through September 1, 2025 [2]
• Second application period: November 1, 2025 through January 15, 2026 [2]
Private schools received in 2023-24—40% more than the previous year $439 million in tuition grants[1]. The state expects to spend about $93 million more [2] once universal access starts in 2026, bringing the total cost to around $674 million [2].
Why Indiana expanded school vouchers
Republican lawmakers who support voucher expansion focus on parents' choice and educational freedom. They believe public schools get better through competition from private schools [3]. Betsy Wiley, who leads the Institute for Quality Education, says that "more options create competition and competition creates quality education" [4].
Critics worry about the program's future. The cost has shot up from its start in 2011 to more than $600 million each year [3]. Democratic lawmakers say wealthy families who can already afford private schools benefit the most. Representative Andrea Hunley points out, "Families who are making well over four hundred, five hundred thousand dollars a year are now going to get state aid to send their children to school" [2].
Impact on public and private schools
Vouchers have changed both public and private education deeply. Private schools see more students and money thanks to vouchers. Students who use vouchers make up more than 90% of enrollment in 178 out of 349 private schools that accept them [5].
Public schools struggle with funding. They lose $6,000-7,000 for each student who uses a voucher because education money follows students in Indiana [3]. South Bend Community School Corporation lost over $21 million in five years [3]. Fort Wayne Community Schools saw about $40 million go to vouchers instead [1].
The program's student profile looks different now. Vouchers started as help for low-income students to leave failing schools. Now, 67.5% of voucher students never went to an Indiana public school—up almost 4 points from last year [1]. Critics say this shows the program mostly helps families who would pick private schools anyway.
How Indiana Compares: Which States Have School Vouchers?
Image Source: The Penny Hoarder
School vouchers are gaining momentum across the country. now offer 23 voucher programs in 2024 13 states plus the District of Columbia [6]. Indiana's Choice Scholarship Program, one of the longest-running programs in the nation, has expanded. Let's learn about how other states handle educational choice to understand Indiana's place in the digital world.
States with universal voucher programs
The push toward universal voucher programs has moved faster over the last several years. No state offered true universal school choice before 2021, but that has changed [7]. across the United States 12 programs now allow universal eligibility[6]. These states have created universal or near-universal voucher programs:
• Arizona (first to introduce universal education savings accounts in 2022) [7]
• Arkansas (Children's Educational Freedom Account Program, 2023) [8]
• Florida (Family Empowerment Scholarship, expanded to all K-12 students in 2023) [8]
• Iowa (Education Savings Account Program, 2023) [8]
• Louisiana (LA GATOR Scholarship Program, 2024) [8]
• Oklahoma (Parental Choice Tax Credit, 2023) [8]
• Utah (Utah Fits All Scholarship Program, 2023) [8]
• West Virginia (Hope Scholarship Program, 2021) [8]
Indiana's move to universal eligibility in 2026 follows this national trend of removing income restrictions from voucher programs.
Key differences between Indiana and other states
Each state's voucher program has its own unique structure. Indiana's program gives 90% of the state's per-pupil funding amount, which averaged $6,264 per student in 2023-24 [2]. Most states follow this pattern, typically providing about 90% of per-pupil funding [2].
Indiana's program is different from Florida's and Arizona's because it keeps income-based eligibility requirements until 2026 [2]. The state's voucher usage shows distinct patterns - 64% of participants are white, 17% Hispanic, and 9% Black [9]. Hispanic and Asian students participate at higher rates compared to statewide demographics [9].
The program's reach tells another story. Only 33% of Indiana voucher recipients in 2023-24 had ever been in public schools [9]. This shows the program now serves more students who were already in private education. Arizona shows similar patterns, where 75% of the original universal voucher applicants never attended public school [10].
Trends in school choice across the U.S.
School voucher programs have transformed American education policy. The number of states offering universal school choice jumped from zero to twelve between 2021 and 2024 [1]. This growth shows strong political support and evolving educational philosophies.
Private school choice has grown from targeted programs to broader offerings [6]. The original programs helped students with disabilities, low-income families, or those in struggling schools. Now, many states have lifted these restrictions.
Program costs have surged as eligibility expands nationwide. Arizona's costs jumped from $33 million to $276 million just six months after expansion [10]. Indiana expects its costs to reach more than $600 million by 2025, nearly double the current amount [10].
Politics plays a big role in these changes. Republican-controlled states lead the voucher expansion movement, while Democratic-led states oppose these measures [7]. By 2025, 12 of the 15 states with universal choice programs will be Republican-controlled, with none in Democratic-controlled states [8].
The makeup of voucher recipients changes as more students join these programs. Both Indiana and Ohio saw increases in white student participation as eligibility expanded, though Indiana's increase was smaller (from 62% to 64%) [2].
Pros and Cons of Using School Vouchers in Indiana
School vouchers present both opportunities and challenges that families must think over carefully. Indiana's program has grown faster, and families face several factors to weigh in this crucial educational decision.
Advantages for families
Parents point to several benefits of private education with voucher support. The freedom to pick schools that line up with their values and educational priorities tops the list [11]. The expanded access lets more than 60% of children in cities like Gary and over 40% in Muncie attend schools their parents believe serve them better [12].
Many backers believe competition from private schools helps raise education quality everywhere [11]. The program's reach has grown beyond just low-income students. Now families of all income levels can participate, with 20% of voucher families earning more than $100,000 each year [13].
Potential drawbacks to think over
The benefits look good on paper, but research shows troubling academic results. A detailed 2018 study found students with vouchers saw "substantial average achievement loss" in math. Their English language arts scores showed no real improvement compared to public school students [3]. These negative effects stayed consistent year after year [3].
Private schools taking vouchers might use selective practices that public schools can't. Rules prevent discrimination based on race, religion, gender, or ethnicity. Yet private schools can still turn away students based on sexual orientation or identity. They might also discourage students with special needs from enrolling [11].
How vouchers affect school funding
Vouchers create ripple effects throughout Indiana's education system. Public schools lose $6,000-7,000 when a student leaves for a private school with voucher support [11]. South Bend Community Schools lost over $21 million in just five years as students transferred with vouchers [11].
The program's cost jumped nearly 800% between 2012 and 2019 across the state [11]. During this time, Indiana cut per-pupil funding for public education by 1.5%. Other states raised their funding by 10.8% on average [11].
Rep. Robert Behning and other supporters say the program saves money in the overall school funding formula because voucher amounts have caps based on public school funding levels [4]. The latest voucher report shows some interesting numbers. The state paid $439 million for vouchers, but would have spent about $516 million if all 70,000 voucher students had stayed in public schools [2].
Planning Ahead: How to Make the Most of School Vouchers
Indiana's voucher program is expanding faster than ever, and families need to act now to get the most from their benefits. The universal eligibility date of June 2026 is approaching. Here's what you can do to set your family up for success.
Evaluating school options early
More families will become eligible for vouchers, which means top private schools will have fewer spots available. You should start your research at least a year before enrollment. Here's what you need to do:
• Check the Indiana Choice Scholarship Program website for current eligibility rules
• Reach out to schools about their application steps
• Visit several schools to see how they teach and what their environment feels like
• Get your eligibility documents ready
Note that you can apply for the 2025-2026 school year during two periods: March 1 through September 1, 2025, and November 1, 2025, through January 15, 2026 [14]. Schools will send approved families award letters that show estimated voucher amounts.
Budgeting for additional education costs
Vouchers typically cover either 90% of public school per-pupil funding or the full tuition and fees—whichever is less [2]. The in 2023-24, while private school's average tuition and fees came to $7,749 average voucher award was $6,264[2]. This means you'll need to budget for:
• Extra tuition costs that vouchers don't cover
• Uniforms and school supplies
• Transportation costs (vouchers rarely cover these)
• Fees for extracurricular activities
Ask for a full breakdown of all school costs beyond tuition before you commit to avoid any surprises.
Preparing for future changes in voucher policies
Indiana's voucher landscape changes faster every year. After the 2023 expansion, the final income eligibility rule (now at 400% of free/reduced lunch qualification) will disappear by June 2026 [15]. The program's cost will likely go up by about $93 million[16], which brings the total estimated cost to $674 million [15].
You should keep track of new laws and changes. Competition for education funding remains strong, and funding formulas might change. Private schools that take many voucher students might ask for extra funding like in charter schools [17]. Your family should stay flexible with educational plans to adapt to these policy changes.
Common Myths and Facts About School Vouchers
Indiana's voucher program expansion across the state has sparked debates, and myths still spread about its beneficiaries and funding structure. Let's take a closer look at what the data tells us.
Myth: Vouchers only help wealthy families
In stark comparison to this popular belief, voucher programs benefit students from many backgrounds. The data shows that 70% of Indiana's voucher students qualify for free and reduced-price lunch, which is much higher than the 47% rate in traditional public schools [5]. The voucher program serves a more diverse student population than public schools, with 57% white students and 43% minority students, compared to 68% white and 32% minority in public schools [5].
The demographics change as programs become universally eligible. States that removed income requirements see new participants mostly from families who already paid for private education. The numbers tell the story - in Arkansas, 95% of universal voucher participants never stepped foot in public schools [18]. Florida shows a similar pattern after expanding eligibility, where only 13% of new voucher recipients came from public schools, while 69% were already in private institutions [18].
Myth: Public schools lose all funding
Public schools keep their federal and local funding even when students leave with vouchers [5]. Voucher students make up about 3% of Indiana's K-12 student population and receive just 2% of education funding [19].
Students with vouchers receive $4,707 on average, which is by a lot less than public school students who get $6,872 [5]. Indiana saved $66 million in 2019-2020 through this program [19]. The state would have spent around $239 million if those 36,707 voucher students had attended public schools, instead of the $173 million given in vouchers [19].
Fact: Vouchers can increase school competition
School choice programs create competition that can improve the entire education system [8]. Vouchers push schools to better serve student needs by removing geographic restrictions on enrollment [8].
Research shows that competition from voucher programs helped public schools perform better [20]. The logic makes sense - schools must adapt when parents have choices [8].
The competition works best when all schools follow similar rules. Critics point out that "private schools get to pick their teams while public schools take every kid who shows up" [21]. This creates an unfair situation where private schools make their own rules but public schools must meet state requirements.
Conclusion
Indiana's school voucher transformation marks a turning point for educational choice in the state. The complete removal of income restrictions by 2026 will give thousands more families access to private education, whatever their financial status. This change follows other states where voucher programs have grown from helping disadvantaged students to offering benefits for everyone.
Families need to think over both advantages and disadvantages before they decide. Vouchers offer educational freedom and can improve competition between schools, but research shows mixed academic results for students who use them. The way funding follows students to their chosen schools continues to affect public school budgets.
Starting early is key for families interested in vouchers. They should research potential schools at least a year before enrollment, know that vouchers might not pay for everything, and keep up with policy changes. As universal eligibility gets closer, competition for spots at popular private schools will heat up.
The school voucher debate touches on deeper questions about what we want from education. Should we put individual choice and customization first, or focus on making public schools stronger for all students? People's views differ sharply on this issue. One thing is clear - Indiana has changed its education system dramatically and now has one of the most extensive voucher programs in the country. The next several years will show if these changes actually improve education for all students.
FAQs
Q1. How does Indiana's school voucher program work? Indiana's school voucher program allows families to use state education funds to pay for private school tuition. Parents can choose a participating private school and receive a voucher to cover part or all of the tuition costs, depending on their income level and the school's fees.
Q2. What are the main advantages and disadvantages of school vouchers? Advantages include increased educational choice for families and potential competition-driven improvements in schools. Disadvantages may include negative impacts on public school funding and mixed academic outcomes for voucher students compared to their public school peers.
Q3. Will Indiana's voucher program be available to all families in the future? Yes, starting in June 2026, Indiana's school voucher program will be available to all families in the state, regardless of income. This expansion removes the current income restrictions and makes the program universally accessible.
Q4. How much financial support do Indiana school vouchers typically provide? Indiana school vouchers generally provide 90% of the state's per-pupil funding amount. In the 2023-24 school year, the average voucher award was $6,264. However, this may not cover the full cost of private school tuition and fees in all cases.
Q5. How can families prepare to make the most of Indiana's expanded voucher program? Families should start researching school options early, ideally a year before enrollment. It's important to budget for additional education costs beyond tuition, understand application periods and processes, and stay informed about ongoing policy changes that may affect the voucher program.
References
[1] - https://americafirstpolicy.com/issues/the-unprecedented-rise-in-school-choice-a-new-era-in-american-education
[2] - https://indianacapitalchronicle.com/2024/10/29/new-report-highlights-indianas-choice-scholarships-as-vouchers-increase-nationwide/
[3] - https://tpcref.org/achievement-impact-of-private-school-vouchers/
[4] - https://www.indianahouserepublicans.com/news/guest-column/behning-indiana-s-bold-vision-for-universal-school-choice/
[5] - https://www.indianacc.org/news/school-choice
[6] - https://www.ecs.org/50-state-comparison-private-school-choice-2024/
[7] - https://journalistsresource.org/education/private-school-vouchers-school-choice-research-2/
[8] - https://reason.org/commentary/public-school-vouchers-could-increase-education-competition/
[9] - https://www.edchoice.org/what-states-tell-us-about-who-is-using-school-choice/
[10] - https://www.chalkbeat.org/indiana/2023/5/10/23718448/school-choice-voucher-expansion-indiana-education-policy-public-funding/
[11] - https://www.indystar.com/story/news/investigations/2024/09/05/unraveling-fiscal-impact-of-school-vouchers-on-education-in-indiana/75054166007/
[12] - https://www.indystar.com/story/opinion/columnists/2025/01/06/indianas-school-choice-program-made-education-worse-opinion/77172130007/
[13] - https://indianacapitalchronicle.com/2023/01/12/expanding-voucher-program-would-be-bad-for-kids-bad-for-indiana/
[14] - https://www.in.gov/doe/students/indiana-choice-scholarship-program/
[15] - https://www.wfyi.org/news/articles/indiana-k-12-education-budget-2026-2027-universal-school-vouchers
[16] - https://www.chalkbeat.org/indiana/2025/04/24/vouchers-for-all-start-in-2026-budget-year/
[17] - https://www.chalkbeat.org/indiana/2024/09/24/private-school-voucher-growth-means-nearly-all-students-can-use-them/
[18] - https://www.politico.com/news/2023/11/22/inside-school-voucher-debate-00128377
[19] - https://evdiomessage.org/school-choice-myths-and-facts/
[20] - https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/33221/1001393-Competitive-Effects-of-Means-Tested-School-Vouchers.PDF
[21] - https://tpcref.org/school-choice-myth-vs-truth/
Note: This article was thoughtfully crafted with the help of AI tools and fine-tuned by me, Dr. Burger, at the Student Evaluation Center, to ensure high quality and accurate information that is essential to for anyone wishing to learn more about becoming a special education advocate. Feel free to reach out to me with any questions you have.
© 2025 Student Evaluation Center, LLC
